
by DONNELLE ELLER | DesMoinesRegister.com

Volume is key in quick-service. Fine dining can generate more revenue. Some operate both.
It’s white linen vs. paper napkins, filet mignon vs. a cheeseburger, a $30 bottle of wine vs. a $3 Bud Light.
In a restaurant war of profitability, what’s the better approach — quick, casual and low cost or a high-end, high-dollar dining experience?
Experts say both can be profitable, depending on how they’re operated.
“If you build a quick-service restaurant and do a lot of volume, you can make a lot of money,” said Paul Rottenberg, president of Orchestrate Management & Associates in Des Moines, a group that owns both quick-service and fine-dining restaurants with chef George Formaro. “But your potential is higher if you hit gold with fine dining because you’re generating a lot more revenue.”

Profit margins on both are similar, said Rottenberg, who owns high-end places like Centro and Django and quick-service joints like South Union Bread Cafe and the new East Village restaurant, Zombie Burger + Drink Lab.
A 4 percent profit margin — four cents returned on every dollar of sales — is common for restaurants, experts say.
Several Des Moines restaurant owners and operators have combined both models: Centro is next door to South Union; Gusto Pizza has a restaurant and a food truck; across the street from Proof, a high-end lunch spot, is Flour, a quick-serve pizza counter; Full Court Press’ moderately priced restaurants include Fong’s Pizza and High Life Lounge as well as Sbrocco, a wine bar and fine-dining restaurant on Court Avenue.
Matthew Goodman is among the multitaskers. He owns the Flying Burrito restaurant in Ames as well as vending carts. He moved his restaurant to Iowa State University’s Campustown to take better advantage of college traffic, already crucial to his cart business.
“We make our money in a rush,” said Goodman about his cart business. “If it’s an Iowa-Iowa State game, we won’t stop selling from 7 p.m. to 4 a.m. But if it’s a February weekend, it might be 1:45 to 2:15 in the morning.
“If not for robust months in the fall and spring, we could never survive,” he said.
Rottenberg said his restaurants gain efficiencies combining approaches, such as sharing kitchens or making bread and soups for more than one location. “We can hedge our bets a little,” said Rottenberg.
Josh Holderness, managing partner at Gusto Pizza, said the pizza truck helps market the Ingersoll Avenue business as well as generate income. “The restaurant is our bread and butter,” he said. “But we use the truck to help build a following.”
The recession helped reduce costs for the new business, which opened in January, said Holderness. “It was a good time to get into a lease and a great location. We had more options available to us because of the economic climate,” he said.
The recession has changed little about Full Court Press’ approach, said Jeff Bruning, a partner. The group is always sensitive about the prices it charges, whether it’s a $3.75 cheeseburger at the High Life Lounge or a $24 Niman ranch pork chop meal at Sbrocco.
“The difference is whether the food is delivered with a short truck or long truck,” said Bruning, adding that locally grown organic food prepared by a chef costs more to serve. “Both are good quality, but when you’re buying grass-fed beef, there’s only a few producers and prices are higher,” he said.
Good quality and service are musts for restaurants wanting to thrive, especially when consumers have many choices and limited dollars, said Robert Bosselman, chairman of ISU’s Apparel, Educational Studies and Hospitality Management Department.
“I would want to appeal to the market that had some dollars to spend,” he said. “I would lean toward the higher end. They always have money to go out a few times a week.
“And the level of competition is dramatic for quick-service,” Bosselman said. “The odds of success are much more limited.”
David Horsfield, who leads the Kirkwood Community College culinary program, said success comes down to the owner. “A savvy business manager can make good money in fine dining and quick-service,” he said, adding that his program’s enrollment continues to grow with the rising popularity of the Food Network and celebrity chefs.
“It comes down to the skill of the operator, more so than the talent of the chef,” he said.
Long-term trends favor restaurateurs, said Darren Tristano, executive vice president at Technomic, a Chicago food industry consultant.
The millennial generation, America’s 20-somethings, eat out more often than older generations, he said. The group tends to spend less, a fact that will change as earning power grows.
Baby boomers, mid-40s to 65, have more to spend but more often chose home-cooking, mostly because it’s healthier, Tristano said. And Generation X, consumers in their 30s and early 40s, has less discretionary income for dining out, juggling costs like tuition and mortgages.
“Millennials are very social, and, frankly, don’t know how to cook without a microwave,” Tristano said. “They will be the best targets for restaurants. They will probably bring restaurant dining to new levels.”


















