

By: Nicole Longhini
PHOENIX – For nearly a year, the Baseline Killer was identified by only a sketch.
In September of 2006, Mark Goudeau was arrested and accused of nine murders tied to the Baseline Killer crimes. Valley communities breathed a sigh of relief.
Now, less than three months before Goudeau’s trial is set to begin, ABC15 has uncovered new details about his defense.
A Phoenix police officer, assigned to track down the Baseline Killer, says he believes Goudeau did not commit all the crimes tied to the largest serial killer investigation in Arizona history.
Officer Rusty Stuart is honored and respected by the Phoenix Police Department, according to his personnel file.
He has been a Phoenix cop for 21 years, and was assigned to the Baseline Killer case in 2006.
Stuart told ABC15 that Goudeau may be involved in some of the murders. He also said he is not trying to protect Goudeau.
But when Mark Goudeau goes to trial in January, according to Rusty Stuart and his attorney, Stuart is scheduled to be a witness for the defense – not the prosecution.
That’s because Stuart believes there is another person behind some of the nine murders.
Stuart provided the evidence behind his suspicions while being questioned by Maricopa County Attorneys, as they prepared the case against Mark Goudeau.
“I was very much concerned about him,” Stuart told county prosecutors during taped audio recordings.
The “him” Stuart is referring to in the tapes is Terry Wayne Smith, a California native that lived in Phoenix at the time of the Baseline Killings – and someone with a history of committing violent crime.
“I figured Terry was involved in this,” Stuart said during the recordings. “Terry came home with blood the same day as a homicide.”
Stuart told prosecutors he sees a connection between Smith, Goudeau and the Baseline killings.
Many of Stuart’s theories, which will be used at trial in January, revolve around a map created by Phoenix Police profilers.
There are many marks on the map that indicate where the majority of the crimes tied to the Baseline Killer happened – from rapes to robberies and murders.
The area where the majority of the marks appear on the map is called the 95th percentile, meaning that 95% of the crimes occurred or would have occurred within that area.
But, outside that area, there are three homicides that Goudeau is accused of committing.
Those three crimes are the main focus of Stuart’s proposed testimony in Goudeau’s case.
“They make no sense in the 95% area,” Stuart told County Prosecutors during the taped recordings.
Stuart wants to focus on a double murder that happened inside a mobile lunch truck near 91st Avenue and Lower Buckeye Road, more than 13 miles outside the 95th percentile area.
Stuart told prosecutors that he can place Terry Wayne Smith at the scene of that double murder.
In the tapes, Stuart claimed Terry Wayne Smith was released from jail 48 hours before the lunch truck murders, and he had gone to his mom’s house, who at the time, had moved into a new home five miles away from the scene of the double murder.
The third murder Stuart has tied to Smith happened in Tempe.
In that case, 19-year old Georgia Thompson was shot to death near her apartment complex along Mill Avenue in Tempe.
According to Stuart’s personal case notes, Thompson’s roommate at the time was a woman named “Tiffany.”
Stuart claims “Tiffany” is Terry Wayne Smith’s ex-wife, and that she and Thompson both worked at the same business.
According to their investigative reports, Phoenix Police have not validated the questions raised by Stuart about the Tempe murder.
Audio recordings indicate Stuart wanted to continue his investigation anyway. But,Stuart said he was ordered to stop looking into Terry Wayne Smith.
Officer Stuart claims leaders of the Baseline Task Force told him to back off.
“I was told [Smith] was eliminated, and to basically go away,” Stuart said.
During the audio recordings, Stuart admitted a team of detectives had looked into the possible Terry Wayne Smith connection, and had tossed him out as a suspect because they believed Smith had been in jail during the murders.
“They were under the assumption [Smith] was incarcerated,” Stuart said.
Stuart claims the detectives’ facts were wrong.
“Terry was not in prison, he was out,” Stuart said.
And ABC15 confirmed, Stuart is right.
According to prison records reviewed by ABC15, Smith was not in prison at the time of the murder in Tempe and the double murder on 91st Avenue and Lower Buckeye Road.
During the tapes, Stuart was asked by prosecutors why he was ordered to stop his own investigative work.
According to the audio recordings, Stuart said his superiors told him he was helping Goudeau.
“The response was that I was giving Goudeau a defense,” Stuart said to prosecutors.
That is the response that Goudeau’s defense hopes to hear in court.
But Terry Wayne Smith says he also wants to testify.
While Smith declined ABC15’s request for an on-camera interview, he wrote letters to county prosecutors

















