NEWS FLASH>>> Food Trucks Sue City of Monrovia For Civil Rights Violations

By SoCalMFVA | MobileFoodNews.com

[Los Angeles] – The Law Offices of Dermer Behrendt has filed a lawsuit on behalf of the SoCal Mobile Food Vendors Association (SoCalMFVA) against the City of Monrovia in Los Angeles Superior Court, case number BC458142. The lawsuit seeks to overturn Monrovia’s mobile-food ordinances for the benefit of the food trucks and the consumers of Monrovia. The lawsuit arises from Monrovia’s decision to both expand its laws to include outright bans on gourmet food-trucks and the admissions of its Mayor Pro-Tem and other executives that the objective of the laws are to protect Monrovia’s “Old Town” merchants from competition from the gourmet food-truck “phenomenon.”

The SoCalMFVA is a non-profit association of approximately 130 gourmet food vendors. The Association exists in part to provide a unified voice in engaging local governments on regulatory issues affecting this new industry. As the Complaint describes in more detail, the gourmet trucks’ business model is based upon the economic law that demand, not costs, drives prices. The trucks have discovered that a significant synergy exists when they operate together in addition to the demand created as a result of the diverse food offerings. Consumers are thus the beneficiary of increased access to diverse cuisines and open-space interactive environments.

The Complaint further explains that the success of the gourmet food-truck model has led to a reaction from parochial interests — in this case, the “Old Town” Monrovia merchants. The Complaint provides that “Members of Monrovia’s City Council in trumpeting their handiwork to the media, proclaimed that this new legislation…is a naked restraint of trade created solely to protect its favored interests — certain fixed-location restaurants (particularly in “Old Town” Monrovia) at the expense of Association Members who would otherwise seek to serve Monrovia consumers with a better product at a better price.” The Complaint goes on to explain “Monrovia’s recent legislation has built upon prior local law that is similarly violative of the rights of the Members of the SoCalMFVA.”

“This lawsuit is about protecting the food trucks’ civil rights to operate under the law and without coercive threats of criminal sanction and, consequently, the consumer’s right to access the marketplace without interference from a municipal government that willfully violates established state law and court precedents,” said Jeff Dermer, managing partner of Dermer Behrendt. Dermer, lead counsel on the lawsuit, continued, “City governments should not nakedly protect one class of merchant from competition from another. The Association has been seeking to educate and work with municipalities on these issues, with success. Monrovia’s actions show that the legal process is the only way to ensure Monrovia follows the laws of the State. The relief we are seeking includes preliminary and permanent injunctions against all of the illegal provisions and damages for violation of the trucks’ civil rights.”