Asheville, NC: City Looking at Food Trucks in Biltmore Village

Jerad Rast and Barbara Carpenter wait for their orders as Ashton Ratzlaff serves lunch to customers at the Melt Your Heart Gourmet Grilled Cheese food truck on Coxe Avenue in Asheville. The debate over food trucks picked up again as city officials look at whether the trucks should be allowed in Biltmore Village. / John Fletcher/Jfletcher@citizen-times.com

By Julie Ball | Citizens-Times.com

Jerad Rast and Barbara Carpenter wait for their orders as Ashton Ratzlaff serves lunch to customers at the Melt Your Heart Gourmet Grilled Cheese food truck on Coxe Avenue in Asheville. The debate over food trucks picked up again as city officials look at whether the trucks should be allowed in Biltmore Village. / John Fletcher/Jfletcher@citizen-times.com

 ASHEVILLE — The debate over food trucks apparently isn’t over.

Instead, it has shifted to Biltmore Village, where concerns from some businesses about a coffee truck prompted the city to look into whether the trucks should be allowed in the historic area.

The city’s Historic Resources Commission voted Wednesday to recommend allowing food trucks in Biltmore Village, but with some restrictions, similar to requirements for downtown food trucks.

The recommendation is not binding, and the commission split 5-4 on the issue with one member abstaining.

“It’s not that I don’t believe in food trucks. I’ve been to Izzy’s in Biltmore Village, and I think it’s wonderful. But as a historian, as someone who is trying to uphold guidelines of a historic nature for the district, I don’t believe that food trucks have a place there in the current situation,” commission member Ashley Black said.

The recommendation now goes to the city’s Planning and Zoning Commission, which could make a recommendation to City Council.

The city for years banned food trucks downtown. But after plenty of heated debate that pitted restaurant owners against the food trucks, City Council agreed last year to allow the trucks with restrictions.

The Biltmore Village concerns emerged as the city was doing its one-year review of the ordinance allowing the food trucks downtown, said Alan Glines, city urban planner.

“It became an opportunity to review all the issues, and it was timely to bring it back here (to the Historic Resources Commission),” he said.

Izzy’s coffee truck sparked the discussion after getting a permit to set up in a parking lot in Biltmore Village.

Jeremy Hargroves, who operates the truck, said he went to business owners about his plan to set up two or three days a week in the afternoons.

“I didn’t feel like anybody came up to me and said ‘Hey, we have some issues with mobile food trucks being here’,” Hargroves said.

The only other coffee shop in Biltmore Village is a Starbucks.

“I’m sure we’re not even a blip on their radar,” Hargroves said.

But the truck prompted a request from some Biltmore Village business owners for the city to change the zoning regulations to either prohibit or restrict the trucks in Biltmore Village, city officials say.

The city is home to about 40 trucks. The downtown district is limited to 10 trucks, and unlike other areas, downtown trucks are regulated as a permanent use. Operators can’t use generators, and they must some have some basic facilities, such as sidewalks, Glines said.

Food trucks are only allowed in commercially zoned areas.

Biltmore Village is one of four local historic districts, but the other three are primarily residential.

Stan Collins, owner of the Once Upon a Time children’s book and toy store, said he believes the food truck doesn’t fit with the historic nature of Biltmore Village.

“An area like Biltmore Village or any other historic area, there’s a certain image that goes with that, and I think what we’re talking about, I don’t think fits in with that image,” Collins said.

“People come in here from everywhere, and they love it because it’s an old historic area,” Collins said. “It’s an environment, and a truck in a parking lot selling food is really sort of counter to that concept.”

The commission reviewed three options, including banning all food trucks from Biltmore Village except for special events, a move recommended by staff.

Biltmore Village has particular guidelines for the historic district, said Stacy Merten, the city’s director of historic resources.

“Biltmore Village is a very unique place,” Merten said.

But several people who work in Biltmore Village said in interviews they like having the truck there.

“Where else do you get coffee? It (the truck) is really very nice. It’s not tacky,” said Jean Brown, who works at William & Grace, where the truck parks a few days a week.

Brown said she’s heard no complaints about the truck.

“If you are going to complain about that, you have to complain about every other truck that pulls into Biltmore Village,” Brown said.

Hargroves said, “The only complaint I’ve heard is when we’re not there.”

Eli Masem, who owns the coffee truck Ursa Minor Coffee, said he can’t understand “why it’s such a huge issue.”

“I can’t imagine why that would be a problem there,” Masem said. “These guys have done all their due diligence. They have permission to be there.”

Bringing food trucks to downtown hasn’t created the problems some had predicted, according to Suzy Phillips, owner of Gypsy Queen Cuisine, who spearheaded efforts to bring food trucks downtown.

“The people of Asheville love us, love the food we are putting out,” she said.

 http://www.citizen-times.com/article/20121115/NEWS/311150026/History-collides-food-trucks-Biltmore-Village?odyssey=tab%7Ctopnews%7Ctext%7CFrontpage&gcheck=1&nclick_check=1