Burbank: City Report On Mobile Food Vending

By MobileFoodNews.comAdd an Image


DATE: February 15, 2011
TO: Michael S. Flad, City Manager
FROM: Greg Herrmann, Community Development Director
By: Terre Hirsch, Assistant Community Development Director/License and Code Services Administrator

SUBJECT: STEP ONE REPORT ON MOBILE FOOD TRUCK VENDING

PURPOSE
The purpose of this first step report is to provide Council with information concerning the legality of enforcing Burbank Municipal Code (BMC) section 3-4-1111 regarding the conditions and restrictions for mobile food truck vending (peddling). A copy of BMC 3-4-1111 is attached as Exhibit A.

HISTORY

As defined by the BMC, mobile food truck vending is considered a peddling activity (Exhibit B) and the manner in which mobile food truck vending occurs in Burbank is detailed in the Burbank Peddler Ordinance. This ordinance was amended in 1994 to include conditions and restrictions for peddling activities. The specific conditions and restrictions being discussed in this report are:

  • No peddling within any continuous three hour period of time, no person shall act or operate as a peddler within 1,000 feet of any preexisting location where any sales have occurred; or
  • No person shall act or operate as a peddler at any location for any period of time exceeding 15 minutes.

In October, 2010 staff was contacted by Mr. Kevin Behrendt, an attorney representing the Southern California Mobile Food Vendors Association. Mr. Behrendt brought to staff’s attention appellate case law which determines that regulatory provisions of municipal codes which are not for the purpose of public safety and limit the time, place, and manner in which food truck vendors may operate, are preempted by Section 22355 of the California Vehicle Code (CVC). Therefore food peddler ordinances, such as Burbank’s, are invalid and unenforceable.

After receiving Mr. Behrendt’s notification, staff requested an opinion from the City Attorney’s Office. The City Attorney’s Office opined that this is a correct interpretation of the CVC as it relates to the BMC. Therefore, unless an argument can be successfully made that the provisions of the BMC are in place for public safety, it is staff’s belief that these provisions should be removed from the Peddler Ordinance.

After the initial contact with Mr. Behrendt staff discontinued enforcing the provisions of the ordinance pertaining to time, place, and manner in which food truck vendors may operate in Burbank. However, staff still continues to require mobile food truck vendors to be licensed by the City, which includes public health department inspections and licensing by the Los Angeles County Department of Public Health. This aspect of mobile food truck vending was recently subject to additional county regulations regarding a letter grading system similar to what is in place countywide for fixed location restaurants. At a later date, staff will provide Council with a report concerning the new county letter grading system.

ANALYSIS

CVC Section 22455(a) authorizes street vending from vehicles provided only that they are completely stopped and lawfully parked. CVC Section 22455(b) requires compliance with any local ordinances that may be adopted to regulate the type of vending and the time, place, and manner of street vending but only for the purpose of public safety. To the extent any provisions of the BMC regulating the type of vending and the time, place, and manner of mobile food truck vending upon city streets is not for the purpose of public safety, such provisions would be in conflict with the CVC, and thus, preempted.