
By Peter Heck | The Star Democrat

CHESTERTOWN — The Chestertown council is considering an amendment to the town ordinance regarding food trucks.
The amendment is in response to a request by Ashley Herr. Herr began operating her Black Burro taco truck in August 2014, when the town planning commission unanimously approved her application to set up in the Twilley Lane parking lot in the 200-block of Cannon Street. The approval was for a 90-day trial period to determine the impact of the food truck on the community.
In November, Herr’s attorney sent a proposed amendment to the ordinance on peddlers, under which the food truck was approved, to town hall. It would allow trucks to set up at a number of locations, including Park Row next to Fountain Park, the foot of High Street and in any of the town’s commercial districts. They would not be allowed to set up within 150 feet of an existing restaurant or during farmers market hours Saturday mornings.
Also, the proposed amendment sets a $35 annual license fee for food trucks.
The council discussed the proposal at both of its December meetings. At the Dec. 7 meeting, Mayor Chris Cerino said the request would set a precedent for other food vendors.
Councilman Marty Stetson said he worried about the truck’s effect on downtown restaurants. He said there would be more applications from food trucks if the first was successful. He said restaurants that are paying rent and taxes would be at a disadvantage.
At the Dec. 21 council meeting, Councilman Liz Gross said her research showed that fees for food trucks in other cities run from $150 to $450 annually.
Also on Dec. 21, Town Manager Bill Ingersoll said the issue was whether the trucks should be allowed to set up on public streets as opposed to private property. He said he would draft an amendment incorporating the council’s concerns for a future meeting.
He brought the draft to the Jan. 4 council meeting. It would limit the food trucks to three sides of Fountain Park between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m. except during the farmers market. Other times and locations could be approved by the council case by case. A monthly fee payable in advance, at an amount to be determined by the council, would be required.
Food truck operators would be required to have liability insurance of at least $1 million, with the town as an additional insured. Ingersoll said this was because the town would likely be included in any suit against a food truck operator on public streets.
Also, food truck operators would be required to collect and remove all trash generated by their presence.
Council members had several questions about the ordinance. Councilman Linda Kuiper asked if the town would be liable for problems that arose if trucks set up on private property.
Ingersoll said the town is not liable for trucks operating on private property, which is why the planners approved it. He said Herr’s request to set up on town streets is the reason the amendment is needed.
Gross said a quarterly fee payment would put less burden on the town staff.
Cerino suggested the council read the draft amendment and think about it for possible introduction at the next council meeting, Tuesday, Jan. 19. He said he was “on board conceptually,” because he felt food trucks could attract visitors to downtown, where they might patronize other stores.
Stetson repeated his opposition to the proposal. He said he spoke to five restaurant owners, two of whom were “dead against it.” He said nobody was likely to come downtown just to eat at a food truck.
Jeff Carroll, owner of the Fish Whistle restaurant, said from the audience that he opposed food trucks, even though Herr is a personal friend. He said restaurants must pay property taxes, provide restrooms and meet other requirements food trucks are exempt from. He said business at his former restaurant, the Old Mill, was affected by Herr’s truck, which set up nearby. Fish Whistle’s business hasn’t been affected, he said.
In an email Jan. 4, Herr wrote, “I have been operating for a year and a half. The last few months I have been doing only private parties and some events because I can not rationalize paying the rent on my parking spot to then sit where there is no foot traffic, no one sees me or even knows that I am there.”
She said she set up in more centrally located spots for special events, during which she sold twice as much food as in the Twilley Lane location. She said customers asked why she wasn’t there on a regular basis.
Herr also wrote, “The goal of the amendment is to shrink the town’s original $1000.00 per month fee, which was established to keep ice cream trucks out of the town’s neighborhoods in 1984, and to allow food trucks at locations convenient to the citizens.”
Zoning Adminstrator Kees de Mooy said in a phone interview Dec. 30 he received complaints about Herr’s truck setting up in locations other than the Twilley Lane site. He said he wrote Herr a letter noting the complaints, after which she stopped setting up except during special events, such as the Legacy Day celebration in August and Downrigging Weekend at the end of October.
Around the same time as Herr’s truck was approved, Kevin Miller received approval to operate a food truck selling barbecue, fried fish, burgers and hot dogs. He has operated the truck from a privately owned lot near the roundabout on High Street.
http://www.stardem.com/business/article_cc4535e2-ed7b-5fba-a6d9-54c778f4d0f4.html



















