Greensboro, NC: City Council Stages Its Own Food Truck Fight

City Councilmembers (from left) Zack Matheny, Trudy Wade, Marikay Abuzuaiter, Dianne Bellamy-Small, Mayor Robbie Perkins, Yvonne Johnson, Jim Kee, Nancy Vaughan and Nancy Hoffmann in the council chambers Tuesday night. Photo by: John Hammer.

By John Hammer | Rhino Times

City Councilmembers (from left) Zack Matheny, Trudy Wade, Marikay Abuzuaiter, Dianne Bellamy-Small, Mayor Robbie Perkins, Yvonne Johnson, Jim Kee, Nancy Vaughan and Nancy Hoffmann in the council chambers Tuesday night. Photo by: John Hammer.

Tuesday, August 28, the Greensboro City Council, despite the best efforts of Mayor Robbie Perkins to move on, spent nearly an hour discussing food trucks. And not just food trucks, but food trucks in the downtown. And not just food trucks in the downtown, but specifically whether to pass an ordinance allowing food trucks in the downtown or have a 30-day pilot program during which a limited number of food trucks would be allowed in the downtown on Commerce Place but nowhere else.

How do you limit the number? How much do you charge them to park on the street? How many do you allow? These questions overshadowed the other issues in the city, like one that Councilmember Trudy Wade brought up concerning crime on High Point Road or three that Perkins mentioned: jobs and economic development, public safety and infrastructure.

No, the City Council spent most of its one work session of the month discussing food trucks and whether to lift the ban on them in the downtown permanently or with a pilot program.

In the end, as this council so often does, it punted.

The consensus after the 50-minute discussion was that there was no consensus and the staff would present a plan at the Sept. 4 City Council meeting, a public hearing would be held and then something else would happen. Who knows what. The council has not hired a consultant to prepare a report on food trucks, so that is a possibility. Perhaps a citizens’ task force will be appointed. It would hopefully be made up of 40 or 50 citizens who will meet and dissect food trucks for week after week.

Councilmember Zack Matheny kept trying to convince his fellow councilmembers there was no need for a pilot program. But the Nancys – Councilmembers Nancy Vaughan and Nancy Hoffmann – had reportedly put a lot of work into planning a 30-day pilot program and were not going to be denied their pilot program by someone who wanted to skip the preliminaries and get the job done.

The whole thing got started because Perkins, who does sometimes try to get this council to do something, said about the food truck item later on the agenda: “I think we could go through this in about 30 seconds.” He added, “Everyone has discussed the food truck to death.” So he suggested the council go ahead and get that out of the way before the closed session. The agenda called for the council to immediately go into closed session to discuss City Manager Denise Turner Roth’s evaluation. Please note that it was not to evaluate Roth but to discuss how the council would evaluate Roth. This council doesn’t like to jump into anything.

So when Perkins launched the council into a discussion of food trucks there were some logistical problems. The discussion had been going on for much longer than 30 seconds when City Attorney Mujeeb Shah-Khan got Perkins’ attention and asked if the meeting had started because he did not think the clerk was taking minutes. The assistant city clerk said that she indeed was not taking notes. She hadn’t been prepared to take notes since some councilmember was supposed to read a prepared motion to go into closed session and then they were all going to troop upstairs to another “more secure” conference room where they would hold their closed session. A weekly newspaper reporter in the room offered his excellent notes to the city for the official minutes, but so far the city has not requested them.

After about 10 more minutes of discussion with the clerk taking notes, Perkins said it was clearly not something that could be handled in 30 seconds and suggested that the staff go ahead and give its report. By this time Roth had sent someone upstairs to get her notes, papers, iPhone and iPad for the food truck discussion, which was taking place about an hour before it had been scheduled.

Matheny at the very beginning said, “I think we are setting ourselves up for even greater confusion.” They turned out to be prophetic words.

One point of confusion was that Vaughan kept saying that the pilot program planned for Commerce Place, which is really just a big mostly empty parking lot between Friendly Avenue and Bellemeade Street, was not in the food truck prohibited area downtown. Roth had to correct Vaughan.

Matheny kept pointing out that the city did not need to be in the food truck business. He said, “We couldn’t really manage the farmers’ market. That didn’t work out for us.” And he pointed out that the city was going to pick the vendors that had exclusive rights to the downtown for 30 days and rent them space on a city street for some unknown cost.

Matheny’s suggestion was that the city simply lift the ban and allow food trucks on private property downtown, but that the city shouldn’t pick favorites. He also brought up the point that if the city had a trial period then the council would discuss it and hear from the public before the pilot program and then again if they decided to lift the ban. Nobody on the council seemed to oppose lifting the ban, although since Hoffmann rarely says anything it is difficult to determine where she stands on any issue.

Matheny asked, “What is the point of prohibiting them in the CBD [central business district]?”

Roth answered, “I’m sorry I don’t know.”

It is difficult to convey how refreshing it was to hear those words. In the past city staff has made up the most convoluted answers imaginable to keep from having to say they didn’t know. Perhaps Roth can change the corporate culture.

Perkins noted, “We can regulate this thing to death.”

At one point it looked like Matheny and Perkins were going to be able to push through rewriting the ordinance without Vaughan and Hoffmann’s pilot program, but Vaughan was not about to give up. Hoffmann did answer a question and said, “The concept is fresh food on the truck.”

After some back and forth where Roth was desperately trying to get some direction from the council, Perkins said, “Do them both.”

Matheny noted, “We are going to be talking about this at least three more meetings.”

It seemed impossible, but after that the meeting got even sillier. Roth has a plan to take February One Place and a parking lot just south of the railroad tracks on South Elm Street and put out cafe tables and chairs, string lights over the areas and block them off with planters.

Why anyone would sit at one of these tables was never explained. When asked, Roth said, “We would have downtown ambassadors in the area to take comments on the area.”

Presumably there would be music or food or something to drink, but all the council got was this was something in the Cooper Carey report on the downtown. Roth also said that the Parks and Recreation Department staff would probably be involved in setting things up and taking them down. No one explained where the tables and chairs would come from, but Wade did make a good point. She said, “There are other sections of Greensboro other than the downtown.”

Perkins said several times during the discussions that the council was “down in the weeds.” When doing another survey was brought up Perkins said, “Let’s take a survey of the 268,000 people in Greensboro,” evidently getting a little frustrated.

Toward the end of the meeting Perkins said, “Until we get out of the weeds and get to work on some jobs, we are going to be going around in circles.”

The final result as near as anyone could tell was that the city staff is going to bring back resolutions for a pilot program for food trucks on Commerce Place to please Vaughan and Hoffmann and an ordinance to end the ban on food trucks in the downtown that Matheny kept pushing.

No doubt by Christmas there will be some resolution to the great downtown food truck debate.

As for tables and chairs downtown, the staff is going to move forward on that.

http://greensboro.rhinotimes.com/1editorialbody.lasso?-token.folder=comm/2012/08/30&-token.story=213004.112113&-token.disearea=2&-nothing&-token.disearea=1