Brilliant or Crazy Panel: Food Truck Letter Grades

Brilliant or Crazy Panel: Food Truck Letter Grades

Brilliant or Crazy Panel: Food Truck Letter Grades

Zagat Buzz | NY City Edition

One of the biggest 2010 food stories in New York was the Health Department’s conversion to the letter grade system for restaurant inspections. Will 2011 see the same standard applied to the city’s food trucks? LA recently started grading their mobile eateries, so we thought we’d check with our panel to see if this would work in the Big Apple. Let’s take a look!

Marc Forgione (the new Iron Chef)

Crazy: How can you judge a truck the same as a restaurant? I think what food trucks are doing is great and people should just leave them alone. They don’t have the same space as a restaurant, and they certainly don’t have the same equipment. I am from New York, but I don’t think that the guy I order my hot dog from should have his stand get a letter grade. I get it, health is important no matter what type of environment you are serving food in, but nobody is forcing you to go eat at a food truck. This is a chance you take buying food off a truck. I don’t own a food truck, nor have I operated one, so I’m not an expert. I just know that I personally would not hold a food truck up to the same standards as a restaurant.

Jimmy Bradley (owner of The Red Cat and The Harrison)

Brilliant: It’s important to hold all food-handlers to the same standards whether they have a kitchen, a truck, or a kitchen in a truck.

Jason Litrell (bartender from Death & Co.)

Brilliant: Ummmm, duh? Yes, I believe food trucks should be held to the same standards as restaurants. It’s not okay to serve “dirty food” just because it comes from a truck. We all still have the same sensitive plumbing and it’s the Health Department’s responsibility to protect us from ourselves. One of the major drawbacks of this movement is access to bathrooms for the workers. It kinda begs the question: where do they pee now? Where do they wash their hands? If they’re going to call it “Gourmet Street Food,” I want to know if they’re putting the same intensity into cleaning that bucket of bolts at the end of the day.

So this is brilliant by a split decision – two votes for brilliant, one for crazy. What’s your take? Let us know in the comments.