Brainerd, MN: Brainerd City Council – Food truck veto overturned

Council member Mary Koep checked in with Wallin, who indicated he had no intention
of vetoing the amended ordinance should it pass. The council unanimously passed
both ordinances, overriding the veto.
Brainerd Dispatch file photo

By Chelsey Perkins  |  Brainerd Dispatch

Council member Mary Koep checked in with Wallin, who indicated he had no intention of vetoing the amended ordinance should it pass. The council unanimously passed both ordinances, overriding the veto. Brainerd Dispatch file photo
Council member Mary Koep checked in with Wallin, who indicated he had no intention
of vetoing the amended ordinance should it pass. The council unanimously passed
both ordinances, overriding the veto.
Brainerd Dispatch file photo

The Brainerd City Council unanimously overturned a mayoral veto Monday night and reinstated two ordinances governing food trucks.

In what was only the second time he’s exercised the power since elected in 1998, Mayor James Wallin vetoed the ordinances April 23. Wallin voiced concerns about the effect of food trucks on brick-and-mortar restaurants and the impact on park board authority to control whether the trucks would be permitted in the parks.

The main ordinance in question outlines the permitted boundaries, hours of operation and uses, while the other related ordinance amends the zoning map with overlay districts, allowing operation in eight zones throughout the city.

The main ordinance, initially passed by the council in a 5-2 vote, appeared to allow food trucks and other “transient food units,” including trailers, wagons, carts and seasonal temporary food stands, to operate in city parks without any conditions. It also established a 300-foot buffer from restaurants and bars that serve food, among several other restrictions and permitted uses.

City Attorney Eric Quiring advised the parks and recreation department last week the ordinance “appear(ed) to encroach into park and recreation board’s area of authority.” The city charter grants the park board “control and supervision of all parks, parkways and boulevards within the city.”

Parks and Recreation Director Tony Sailer told the council the park board would like to have a say in where, when and how food units operate in the parks.

Council member Dave Pritschet said he felt it reasonable for the park board to have the authority to place conditions on food truck operation.

“It’s reasonable the parks department has some authority in saying where they can set up,” Pritschet said. “They are ultimately responsible for the upkeep of the grounds.”

Council member Kelly Bevans, who was one of the two “nay” votes in the passage of the original ordinance, said the reason he voted against it was because of the park board authority issue.

“I think we should take this opportunity to clarify that in the ordinance,” Bevans said in proposing an amendment.

City Planner Mark Ostgarden suggested amending the ordinance to read, “Sales are permitted in a city park when approved by the city of Brainerd park board.” He also recommended the council amend the ordinance to clarify the buffer issue, adding the trucks must locate at least 300 feet from a restaurant’s “property line.”

Bevans incorporated Ostgarden’s suggestion into his amendment.

Council member Gabe Johnson, who previously expressed he felt the ordinance is too restrictive and could discourage proprietors, said the changes made it even more restrictive.

“I’m not sure it would be better for it to just fail and create something good or to override,” Johnson said.

He said he would support the ordinance with the hopes it could be revisited in the future. Johnson also noted the council changed the wording on allowing the trucks in the parks last time in part because an owner of a brick-and-mortar restaurant suggested the city should be subject to the same competition it is subjecting businesses to. Revenues from concession stands operated by the parks department support park activities.

“It’s a protectionist policy for our own revenue stream, and it’s not right,” Johnson said.

“There’s possibly reasons that a park board might want to restrict the use of the parks other than competition with the hot dog grill,” Bevans responded.

Council member Mary Koep checked in with Wallin, who indicated he had no intention of vetoing the amended ordinance should it pass. The council unanimously passed both ordinances, overriding the veto.

A third ordinance outlining licensing fees for transient food units appeared before the council for its first reading again, after the council sent it back at its April 20 meeting because of too many questions.

The ordinance as proposed would charge food trucks, wagons and stands a $400 annual fee and food carts a $200 annual fee to operate within the city, with the option of paying a prorated rate on a quarterly basis.

Johnson suggested the inclusion of a one-time fee for operators wishing to participate in individual events and Koep said she would not support the ordinance if small ice cream vendors were required to pay as well.

“I doubt that that’s a huge money making thing,” Koep said. “It’s kind of nice and picturesque.”

Ostgarden clarified that technically, city ordinances do not allow ice cream trucks to sell in city streets at all, including in the food truck ordinance. Sales on street right-of-way and sidewalks are not permitted.

Council President Gary Scheeler said he did not support the idea of prorating fees.

“You know nobody is looking from November through April anyway,” Scheeler said.

The council decided to strike the ability to prorate from the ordinance, along with incorporating an option presented by Ostgarden in a memo to set fees at $500 for food trucks, $400 for trailers and wagons and $200 for all others. The council also directed staff to research further the idea of offering a single-day license.

The first reading passed 6-1, with Johnson opposed. The ordinance will appear again before the council for a second reading and public hearing.

http://www.brainerddispatch.com/news/3738394-brainerd-city-council-food-truck-veto-overturned