
By Josh Brokaw | Ithaca
Common Council will soon have a decision to make on whether the Hot Truck can move from its current location on Stewart Avenue to a new spot higher up in Collegetown.
The Board of Public Works expressed majority disapproval at its May 18 meeting for extending the “historic exception” the Hot Truck enjoys from the mobile vending law the city enacted in 2014. The Hot Truck, along with Louie’s Lunch, doesn’t have to move from its spot on an every night basis, unlike other trucks that operate under the city law.
Forrest Crawford is a co-owner of Collegetown Crepes, one of the two new food trucks, which currently use city streets under the new permit system. The crepes truck parks at the intersection of Dryden Road and Eddy Street, where Al Smith of Shortstop Deli hopes to move the Hot Truck.
Crawford told the board on Monday that the city acted properly to “grandfather” the two trucks into their spots, but allowing them to move would undermine the spirit of fair competition on the street.
Allowing the Hot Truck to move would create a “new immobile vending policy,” Crawford said. “It’s not at all clear from the proposed resolution whether the spot in Collegetown would be available for other trucks—and even if the spot is left to us, at best, it puts us at enormous competitive disadvantage.”
Crawford told the board that since he and his partner Max Richman opened the crepes truck last October, “on good nights of the week we do really well. We’ve been at events at most of the sororities on campus, some of the fraternities, we’ve been at the farmers’ market.”
“I’d be honestly heartbroken to see it lost to special circumstances,” Crawford said.
Public works commissioner David Warden had the most to say out of all board members against the Hot Truck exception.
“We were trying to encourage other trucks [with the new policy], and now we have another truck, and we’re going directly in conflict with that,” Warden said. “I’m not happy with this resolution. I understand the historical significance, but times change.”
For now, competition for prime Collegetown vending spots is fairly genteel. New in the market are Collegetown Crepes and the sushi truck (That’s How I Roll), and there is a second potential food truck parking spot at the corner of Dryden and Eddy, where, if the Hot Truck is allowed to move, another mobile truck could park if they win a lottery among all applicants. In total, there are about 27 spots approved for food truck occupation in the city.
In the future, though, Jonathan Greene worried that approving an exception would be “awkward” if several trucks were competing for the same spot. Bill Goldsmith proposed that the city subsidize wheels for the Hot Truck, rather than deal with making exceptions to set policy.
Mayor Svante Myrick told Crawford that the crepier’s concerns were a reminder of the arguments brick-and-mortar restaurants made when the city was talking about the mobile vending policy, so far as the “level playing field” argument goes.
The mayor told the board that he was conducting a “heat check” on the Hot Truck exception. He’s been a staunch supporter of the move, and after finding he was outnumbered, said he would beg the board’s forgiveness and bring the issue before Common Council.
“I thought the historical value of the Hot Truck was too high to throw away,” Myrick said. “I thought that it being near the center of student nightlife was more important than an actual set of coordinates.”
Myrick did agree with most in the room that if the Hot Truck should age out and get movable wheels, the exemption would end.
Common Council next meets on 6 p.m. on June 3 in City Hall.




















