Washington, DC: Food Truck Proposal Criticized for Being Anti-Competitive, Protectionist

By Contributor

DC-washington-foodtruck-

WASHINGTON, DC – Mayor Vincent Gray’s proposed new food truck rules were criticized this week for trying to protect brick-and-mortar restaurants from competition and creating stringent, arbitrary limits on food trucks where District residents want them the most.

“Is this a legitimate role for government to play?” asked Washington Examiner columnist Tim Carney. “Should D.C. councilmen … be protecting restaurants from food trucks? Should Vincent Orange protect bookstores from Amazon? Maybe Mayor Gray should protect bike messengers from email.”

Washington Post columnist Alexandra Petri wrote: “Why distribute the slots by lottery, which, as Food Truck Association chairman Doug Povich noted, would effectively put vendors out of business for a month without giving the city much additional revenue. ‘If you don’t win the lottery, you’re out of business for a month. It seems crazy to have a business model based on a game of chance!’”

“What problem is this proposal intended to solve?” asked Slate correspondent Matthew Yglesias. “I don’t hear any clear rationale for these rules, and the only real beneficiaries would seem to be owners of non-mobile downtown lunch businesses.”

“The Food Truck Association of Metropolitan Washington supports smart management of individual locations where food trucks are in greatest demand,” Povich said. “But this proposal seeks to impose a one-size-fits-all approach that so severely restricts where food trucks can operate it threatens the existence of the food truck industry as we know it.”

In case you missed it, here is the latest news about Mayor Gray’s proposed food truck regulations:

Sam Whitfield, co-owner of Curbside Cupcakes, says, “I believe that we can help along with the city put together some regulations that do maintain public health and safety, but also don’t limit our customers’ choice and competition.”

Doug Povich, Chairman of the Food Truck Association of Metropolitan Washington, says lottery winners “are the winners for the entire month, so the losers are out of luck.”

“We started off supporting the regulations two years ago, but now we’re at a point with all of the changes and additions that we just can’t,” Povich said.

DC Mayor Vincent Gray has proposed cruel food truck regulations that would severely hurt small business owners in the District. If the rules pass, food trucks will be illegal in most of downtown DC and the dreams of countless entrepreneurs will be crushed.

“The proposed regulations have one outcome – less choice and competition for District resident’s dollars and fewer food trucks just where residents want them the most,” said Povich.

  • City Paper: Food Truck Association Says Proposed Rules Would Force Them Out of Downtown

According to a sidewalk survey just released by the Food Truck Association of Metropolitan Washington, the rules would make most of downtown off-limits, unless trucks won limited lotteried spots for special zones.

New legislation has been proposed in Washington D.C. that would dramatically restrict the trucks’ movements, and some owners say the new laws would effectively make food trucks illegal in most of the city.

While city officials defend the regulations as a way to balance the needs of the food trucks against those of traditional brick-and-mortar restaurants, the Food Truck Association says that they will simply push food trucks to places where they won’t be able to make enough money to survive.

D.C.’s restaurant lobbyists, along with many local politicians and bureaucrats, seem to think the government’s job is to save the delis and diners, bistros and brasseries from the scourge of falafel trucks, barbecue buses and weenie wagons.

Overall these new changes don’t seem to bode good things for D.C. food trucks (or people who love D.C. food trucks for that matter).

If a new food truck proposal goes through it could limit your lunchtime options and put others out of business.

I know some people of a market urbanist persuasion take the view that trucks’ very existence is a sign of the failure of zoning codes and regulations, but I actually think trucks are an important lunch solution on the merits. Office workers like a diverse array of lunch choices, but they also like to get lunch very close to their office.

If you are willing to stand in line for an ungodly amount of time, as people jostle past you with trays of barbecue, and pay exactly the same amount that you would pay to sit in the comparative peace and order of a Cosi, at a table, like a civilized human, why should the city be so eager to stop you?

About the Food Truck Association 

The Food Truck Association is a group of more than 50 local food truck owner-operators. We seek to sustain the wellbeing of our industry, foster a sense of community and work in partnership to improve food truck regulations. We are engaged community members who deeply care about our city and believe in working together to make a positive impact. The Food Truck Association’s signature event is the Curbside Cookoff food truck festival series. For more information visit www.DCFoodTrucks.org.